Chapter 58 Bah! Unscrupulous journal!

Ten minutes later, in the editor-in-chief's office at CPDE.

Professor Panos looked at the paper paper Wilson had brought and, after hearing about Glenn Arthur, became furious.

"That Glen Arthur is absolutely outrageous!"

Does he think he's funny?

"You did the right thing, Wilson. There's no point in keeping an irresponsible reviewer like that around!"

"While our CPDE journals may not be on par with the top-tier journals, we certainly don't lack reviewers!"

These words have essentially defined the nature of the matter!

Moreover, Professor Panos did not dwell on this matter for long.

He was more concerned about the paper in front of him than about that matter.

After a moment's thought, he asked, "Wilson, so far, has no journal formally published Lin Feng's paper?"

"That's right!"

Wilson nodded.

"When we were researching Lin Feng from Jiangyang Normal University, we found out that he has not published any papers."

I've also been following the paper "Regarding Forest Boundaries," but it's only publicly available on Ariv and hasn't been submitted to any formal journal yet.

The more Professor Panos listened, the brighter his eyes became.

No journal has officially published Lin Feng's paper yet?

This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for them, CPDE!

As I said before, Lin Feng is currently the most popular figure in the entire international mathematics community!

Mathematicians around the world are studying the forest boundary he proposed, and even top international universities and mathematical research centers are trying to find his contact information.

However, to this day, Lin Feng has not published a single paper in a formal journal.

And they, CPDE, happen to have one in their hands!

Although it's not the "Lin Boundary" paper that caused a major earthquake in the entire mathematics community, the author is Lin Feng, Jiangyang.

Lin Feng from Normal University!

That's enough!

If this paper can be officially published before that "Forest Boundary" paper, then their CPDE can directly raise a banner: Lin Feng's paper is the first to be published!

Thinking of this, Professor Panos became quite excited!

For a journal, the quality of its papers determines its academic influence, but hot topics, attention, and topicality can also affect the journal's downloads, subscriptions, circulation, and even its future academic impact factor.

Why not do something that can attract the attention of the entire mathematics community worldwide?

Moreover, their journal also has circulation targets, and this gimmick will likely help them achieve a significant portion of those targets!

Thinking of this, he immediately said, "Listen, Wilson, immediately initiate the emergency peer review process and send this paper to multiple external reviewers simultaneously."

"Expedit all processes!"

"As long as there are no problems with this paper, we will accept it and publish it as quickly as possible!"

Upon hearing this, Wilson also became excited.

That was actually his purpose in coming to find Panos.

Because he also thought that this paper might be an opportunity.

This is an opportunity for them to enhance their influence in the CPDE field, and also an opportunity for their sales to skyrocket.

Without hesitation, after receiving permission, he immediately said that he would make the arrangements right away.

Immediately, one urgent invitation after another for external review was sent out.

Not only that, after submitting it, he also made a special phone call to each of them: "Professor Burke, we hope you can complete the review of this paper as soon as possible. This paper is very important to our journal!"

"In addition, this paper has undergone preliminary verification by our editorial department and fully complies with the latest proposed forest boundary issue."

"This paper is highly innovative in terms of singular boundaries, perturbation compensation, and solution support optimization."

"We hope you will focus on reviewing its proof process, scope of application, and academic value!"

To avoid a repeat of Professor Arthur's blunder, he specifically stated that the paper fully complies with LinBound.

ary.

Of course, because CPDE has always used a double-blind peer review process, even in the case of expedited peer review, he did not disclose the author's information.

And that is precisely why—

When these reviewers received the invitation, their first reaction was one of surprise.

Does it fully conform to the forest boundary?

Today, they have seen far too many papers that do not conform to forest boundaries, some of which have already been published and others that are under review.

Many of these are classic papers that have been cited for many years.

Now, the CPDE editorial department has explicitly stated that this paper fully conforms to forest boundaries?

They even initiated an emergency peer review process?

This piqued their interest!

"interesting!"

"This set of judgment criteria has only been made public for less than a day, and someone is already able to apply it completely?"

"I'd like to see what kind of paper can claim to have a complete grasp of the forest boundaries!"

Professor Burke of Paris-Saclay University said with some curiosity.

Not only him, but the other reviewers were also extremely curious.

They opened the paper and started reading, but as they read, their expressions changed!

This paper studies the unbranched offset problem caused by small initial perturbations under singular boundary conditions.

Unlike traditional methods that directly add a constraint to force a particular solution, this paper introduces the concept of perturbation compensation.

which is:

Based on the propagation results of boundary information in different iteration processes, the effective domain is dynamically modified, and the solution selection is re-completed in the modified true solution space.

The entire process not only takes into account dynamic boundaries and changes in the defined domain, but also the problem of intermediate domain shifts that may be caused by different perturbation sequences.

Furthermore, the cases of local propagation, global propagation, and finite-step convergence were also discussed separately. Although the proof was not very detailed, it can be seen that this is not just in line with the forest boundary, but rather a practical application of the forest boundary.

What surprised them the most was:

Why do I keep seeing the shadow of that paper on Ariv when I read this paper?

In particular, some of their construction ideas seem to have an inexplicable similarity!

If the forest boundary paper was a complete review framework, then this paper applies it in its entirety to the singular boundary solution problem.

It's simply that there's a lack of evidence in some places, and some steps are skipped.

But after they verified and added it, they found that there was no problem at all!

Moreover, the paper presents a very novel and complete approach, and is also highly valuable for practical application!

The more these reviewers read, the more shocked they became!

It can be said that the author of this paper's understanding of boundary presupposition, domain shift, and solution space consistency is likely no worse than that of Lin Feng himself!

When this conclusion was reached, everyone was even more stunned.

Of course, if Professor Arthur knew this, he would definitely say something like:

I already said it! What does Lin Feng know about Lin Bianjie?

However, these are all jokes.

They all gave this paper very high praise.

At the same time, all of them were given the review opinion of "recommend direct hiring".

Professor Burke of Paris-Saclay University stated that he would check the authorship of the paper as soon as it was published.

The reason he did this was because he was too curious.

Less than a day after the concept of the forest boundary was proposed, and while many people were still studying, understanding, and verifying it, some people have already put it into practice?

And you use it so skillfully?

This is absolutely unbelievable!

Who exactly is this top mathematician?

He made many guesses, but none of them seemed very likely.

The other reviewers were also quite confused.

But there's nothing I can do but wait for the next issue of CPDE to be released, buy a copy, and read it to find out the answer.

In less than an hour, all the review comments were sent to Wilson.

CPDE quickly made the decision to accept the offer!

This means that the review process, which normally takes CPDE six months to a year to complete, was finished in just one or two hours this time.

All urgent requests!

Various queue-jumping incidents!

But this matter did not end there.

The next issue of CPDE was originally scheduled to be released in three days.

Moreover, all of them have been printed. Although they have not been sent out yet, the cover, table of contents, and order of the papers have all been finalized!

According to the normal procedure, even if Lin Feng's paper is accepted, it can only be scheduled for the next issue.

But as I said before, CPDE is racing against time right now.

If they wait until the next round, that's next month, and they simply can't afford to wait that long.

To use an old Chinese saying, it's like waiting until the daylily buds have gone cold!

When that time comes, some journal might publish "Forest Boundary" first, and then they won't have any advantage at all.

Furthermore, this paper cannot be posted online.

It's true that you can publish online first, but they're lying, creating hype, and trying to boost sales!

Post it online?

What's the point then!

People will know they're lying the moment they step in!

With this in mind, Professor Panos immediately made a decision:

Destroy all printed copies of the journal, add Lin Feng's paper to the journal, and rearrange the cover and table of contents, placing the paper in the most prominent position in the entire journal.

It was even used as the cover article!

And at the same time, create a buzz!

Let the entire mathematics community around the world know that it was CPDE who completed the first publication of Lin Feng's paper!

Increase publicity efforts!

Everyone must know this!

Of course, this also presents a problem: the original cover article needs to be removed, and the author of that article is a very famous professor in the field of partial differential equations at Oxford University.

Wilson had assumed that the other party would be somewhat dissatisfied after hearing the news.

After all, the cover article had already been confirmed and communicated, but now they want to destroy the already printed journal and remove the other party's cover.

Anyone in that situation would probably feel uncomfortable.

Unexpectedly, when Wilson explained that it was to ensure Lin Feng's paper was published for the first time, the other party not only wasn't angry, but instead said, "I completely agree!"

"The whole world is now studying forest boundaries!"

"I didn't expect that CPDE would be the first to publish this paper; it definitely should have been placed in the most prominent position!"

"My paper is simply not comparable to this one!"

"I support your decision!"

"Furthermore, please let me know as soon as the journal is officially published, as I would like to subscribe as well."

Upon hearing this, Wilson realized that the other party had misunderstood.

But he didn't explain, because that was exactly the effect he and Professor Panos wanted.

It wasn't just him; after the news of "Lin Feng's paper being published for the first time" was posted on the CPDE website and its accounts on various official academic forums, it caused a sensation throughout the international mathematics community: "What? CPDE actually managed to snatch Lin Feng's paper?"

"How could it be CPDE? Publishing this paper there would be beneath its standards!"

"Let me state upfront that I don't mean any disrespect to CPDE, but this is just too unexpected!"

"By the way, how did CPDE get in touch with this mathematical genius?"

The crowd was buzzing with discussion.

Originally, many journal editors had their eyes on the paper "Forest Boundary" and wanted to publish it first.

Therefore, they left various messages on ariv.

And this was exactly what Xie and Mu saw.

But they never expected that CPDE would snatch this paper away.

This is so painful!

They all started pounding their chests and stamping their feet in frustration!

The editors of the Journal of Mathematics, one of the four top journals, were particularly stunned!

Why did Lin Feng choose CPDE instead of them?

Could it be—

Did CPDE save the galaxy in its past life?

Or did they use some divine power?

This is completely unreasonable!

They just couldn't understand it!

What's even more distressing for the major journals is—

CPDE has also opened a pre-order channel for the latest issue of its print journal. Following the announcement, university libraries around the world...

Mathematical research centers, professors, scholars, experts, students—countless people have pre-ordered this issue's print version!

In less than an hour, the number of pre-orders for CPDE, which originally sold only about 1400 copies per issue, jumped to 16000.

Book!

Sales have increased more than tenfold!

Now, the journal editors were even more uneasy!

They never expected that a simple publicity campaign about "Lin Feng's paper being published for the first time" could have such a huge impact!

Their eyes turned red as they watched the numbers constantly fluctuating on the CPDE website!

These should have been theirs to begin with!

If Lin Feng had chosen them, then their official website would be experiencing a surge in traffic, and their journals would be seeing a surge in pre-orders.

But Lin Feng chose CPDE!

Thinking of this, they were filled with both jealousy and hatred!

Not only that, they also took action one after another.

Previously, they had simply left a message on the arXiv page of Lin Feng's paper inviting him to contribute. Although their tone was polite, it still carried a certain arrogance of a top international journal.

Especially some top journals, in their view, the fact that they were willing to take the initiative to invite Lin Feng to submit an article already showed them enough sincerity.

If Lin Feng sees this, he will most likely contact them.

But now they don't think that way anymore. CPDE has already snatched this paper away, and if they continue to hold back, they might lose future achievements.

As I said before, with the release of this paper, no one can doubt Lin Feng's talent and future potential.

And for this reason, the comment section for Lin Feng's preprint on arXiv has become even more lively.

The French Journal of Pure Applied Mathematics:

We sincerely invite Mr. LinFeng to submit his next research findings to this journal, and we are willing to initiate the highest level of expedited peer review process.

Advances in Mathematics:

If Mr. LinFeng has any new research papers, this journal can immediately organize renowned experts in the relevant field to review them upon receipt.

Such as these!

Countless!

Each and every one of them was extremely sincere!

Some journals even sent out invitations in Chinese!

The word "humble" is the only way to describe it!

Among them, Harrison, the deputy editor of the Duke Journal of Mathematics, was the most anxious.

Through a Chinese friend, he quickly obtained the phone number of an elderly professor from the Department of Mathematics at Jiangyang Normal University.

at the same time.

Xie Yongsong and Mu Changxing paid no attention to the international turmoil.

After reviewing the invitations to submit their work on Ariv, the two began discussing the same issue: which journal to choose for submission.

Just then, Xie Yongsong's phone suddenly rang.

Upon opening it, I discovered it was a foreign number!

-

This puzzled him, but he didn't hang up immediately. Before he retired, he received many foreign calls.

"Hello, are you Professor Xie Yongsong from the School of Mathematics at Jiangyang Normal University?"

"I'm Harrison, the associate editor of the Duke Mathematics Journal. I'd like to ask if you have Lin Feng's contact information?"

Hearing this, Xie Yongsong was somewhat surprised.

Surprisingly, Duke Mathematics Journal, one of the "Big Four" journals, even managed to find his phone number.

It seems they're here again because of Lin Feng's paper in Ariv.

The sincerity in inviting this article is practically overflowing!

Mu Changxing, too, was deeply moved:

Even he had never enjoyed such treatment!

However, Xie Yongsong did not directly reveal Lin Feng's contact information, but instead said, "Lin Feng is my student."

What he said was actually not wrong.

Upon hearing this, Harrison became instantly excited.

"What! Your student?"

"That's great! Professor Xie, could you please persuade Lin Feng to withdraw his manuscript from CPDE and submit it to our *Duke Mathematics Journal* instead?"

"We are willing to activate the highest level of peer review!"

"Moreover, the review and release will be completed as quickly as possible!"

Upon hearing this, Xie Yongsong and Mu Changxing were both extremely surprised!

Are even the "Big Four" now so humble?

but----

What's the story behind withdrawing CPDE's manuscript?

"What CPDE?"

Xie Yongsong said subconsciously.

Harrison was taken aback by these words.

"Aren't you Lin Feng's teacher? You didn't know?"

"Know what?"

Xie and Mu were both stunned.

"That's right, CPDE just announced that they will soon publish Lin Feng's latest paper, and they've even advertised it as the first publication by Lin Feng!"

Upon hearing this, the two men's expressions became even stranger.

Just moments ago they were sitting here discussing which journal to publish this paper in, and now they're being told it's been submitted and is about to be published?

What's going on here?!

Did Lin Feng submit the article himself?

That's impossible!

Isn't he practicing his civil service exam right now?

But Xie Yongsong quickly realized, "I understand."

"What they published should be Lin Feng's previous submission, 'Research on Singular Boundary Solution Support Optimization Based on Perturbation Compensation'."

"It's not the one on arXiv right now. CPDE deliberately didn't explain the content clearly, and they're using Lin Feng's current popularity to create hype."

These words were not only spoken to Mu Changxing, but also to Harrison.

There was silence on the other end of the phone, clearly taken aback by the answer.

Almost half a minute passed before Harrison asked, "So, that paper on Ariv hasn't actually been submitted yet?"

"No, not at all."

Xie Yongsong replied.

"Could you perhaps give our *Duke Mathematics Journal* priority consideration?"

Harrison pressed on with more questions.

"Excuse me, Editor-in-Chief Harrison, we need to discuss this matter with Lin Feng."

"We'll contact you once we've made up our minds!"

Xie Yongsong did not agree immediately.

After exchanging a few more pleasantries, the two finally hung up the phone with Xie Yongsong saying "OK, OK".

As soon as the call ended, Harrison, in the editorial office of the Duke Journal of Mathematics, looked at the ever-increasing reservation numbers on the CPDE website, and his face instantly turned extremely grim.

He couldn't help but spit on the ground: "Pah!"

"5

"scam journal!"

(Unscrupulous journal!)

>

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like