Chapter 57 Lin Feng Doesn't Understand Lin Bianjie?

Wilson was stunned when he saw the information displayed in the submission system's backend.

He rubbed his eyes, and then looked at it again.

Same as always!

Nothing has changed!

It's Lin Feng from Jiangyang Teachers College!

In other words, just now, Professor Arthur rejected Lin Feng's paper on the grounds that it "did not meet the requirements of LinBoundary"!

Wilson pulled up the email and read through the reviewers' comments, the affiliations, and the authors in the system backend several times. He really didn't know what to say.

Does Lin Feng's own paper not meet the Lin boundary he proposed?

Isn't this a bit too outrageous?

Therefore, instead of sending a rejection notice directly, he made a phone call to Professor Glenn Arthur.

The call was answered quickly.

"Wilson?"

"Why are you calling me all of a sudden? Is it about manuscript CPDE-2019-1187?"

Professor Arthur on the other side was very puzzled.

"That's right!"

Wilson looked at the computer screen and said, "Professor Arthur, I need you to double-check the peer review comments on this paper."

"Should we double-check?"

Upon hearing this, Professor Arthur was visibly taken aback, and his face immediately darkened.

What does that mean?

Questioning his peer review results?

Just an hour ago, he had been warned by the editorial department for failing to detect forest boundaries in his previous paper.

That incident already made him feel very embarrassed!

Therefore, when reviewing this paper, "Research on Singular Boundary Solution Selection Optimization Based on Perturbation Compensation", he specifically focused on the consistency between the true domain and the solution space.

To prevent himself from making the same mistake again, he even raised the inspection standards significantly. As a result, Wilson is now asking him to verify it again?

What's wrong?

Do you really think he'll make the same mistake twice in a row?

He's a professor at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign!

He is a renowned expert in the fields of singular perturbations, free boundaries, and nonlinear partial differential equations!

He is also a senior external auditor who has been working with CPDE for over ten years!

How can this be questioned repeatedly?

Thinking of this, he immediately said, "Wilson, I don't think there's any need to re-verify."

"This paper definitely does not meet the LinBoundary requirement!"

"I've learned from the lessons of my previous paper and have specifically checked the domain transformations, boundary structures, and solution space consistency involved in this paper!"

"Although the author proposed a perturbation compensation method, he did not prove separately that after each compensation, the new effective domain is still compatible with the original boundary constraints."

"This is precisely the issue that LinBoundary needs to focus on most!"

His tone was very certain!

He missed it in the previous paper; that was his mistake.

But he was absolutely certain that he had not made a mistake with this paper!

Otherwise—

Didn't he fall down in the same place twice?

He then went on to emphasize, "I know the editorial department values ​​Lin Boundary very much, and so do I."

"After receiving the internal warning, I studied the core criteria in that paper very carefully again."

"Therefore, I now clearly understand what kind of papers qualify for LinBoundary and what kind do not!"

"The CPDE-2019-1187 manuscript only provides the compensation operator, but does not list the boundary consistency proof separately."

"That's the problem!"

"I believe my peer review comments were correct!"

If the previous answer was affirmative, then this one can be described as unequivocal.

Without the slightest hesitation!

Upon hearing this, Wilson's expression became extremely strange.

If he hadn't seen who the author of the paper was, he would have believed Professor Arthur's words that the paper was problematic.

But the key point is—

This is Lin Feng's own thesis!

Does this paper not conform to forest boundaries?

Isn't this a joke?

Thinking of this, he slowly said, "So, Professor Arthur, you mean that Lin Feng's own paper didn't meet the boundary conditions he proposed, and therefore you rejected it?"

'

""

The other end of the phone went silent instantly.

Professor Glenn Arthur didn't react at first.

"What?"

Wilson repeated, "Didn't you hear me, Professor Arthur?"

"I said, the author of this paper, 'Research on Singular Boundary Solution Selection Optimization Based on Perturbation Compensation,' is named Lin Feng!"

"It's Lin Feng from Jiangyang Normal University!"

'

"That's the author of the paper 'Global Systemic Deviation of Boundary Presuppositions in Differential Derivation and the Theory of Iterative Domain Reconstruction'!"

"He's also the one who proposed the 'forest boundary' concept!"

"Now you're telling me that you used his proposed forest boundary to prove his paper is wrong, and then suggested we reject his manuscript?"

Professor Arthur finally realized what was happening.

But because of this, he was completely stunned, as if struck by lightning.

He never imagined that his simple desire to prove his knowledge of the "forest boundary" would actually prove T...

The original author's head?

this----

"Really? If it's LinFeng, how could he not have separately proven the boundary consistency after the domain transformation in his paper?"

He asked hurriedly, sounding very anxious.

This matter concerns his academic reputation, and there is no room for error.

Is it possible that this part of the proof doesn't need to be listed separately at all?

"Or rather, LinFeng has already completed the proof in the construction of the perturbation compensation operator, but just didn't write it out separately in the form you're familiar with?"

Upon hearing this, Professor Arthur opened his mouth, wanting to refute, but the words wouldn't come out.

If the author were someone else, he could still stick to his own judgment.

But the author happens to be Lin Feng, the one who proposed the concept of "Lin Boundary"!

Does he really not know how to satisfy Lin Bianjie?

In an instant, his heart sank to the bottom.

Moreover, his so-called "dissatisfaction" was merely because the paper's authors did not list that part of the proof separately, and he did not fully verify the structure of the perturbation compensation operator, nor did he continue to deduce it further.

It's just that because the previous paper was misreviewed and I was warned by the editorial department, I'm eager to prove that I have mastered the forest boundary and that I won't make the same mistake again.

Upon seeing similar questions, I immediately rejected the paper.

"Wilson, you said—"

Is it possible that Lin Feng doesn't actually understand "the boundaries of the forest"?

Glenn Arthur paused for a moment before finally speaking.

"That's great!"

Wilson didn't find the joke funny.

Does Lin Feng not understand Lin Bianjie?

How could Professor Arthur say something like that!

If even the person who proposed this theory doesn't understand it, then what about all these people around the world who are using forest boundaries to review papers?

Moreover, this paper was submitted much earlier than the paper on iterative domain reconstruction theory was published!

It is highly likely that Lin Feng discovered the domain problem in traditional differential derivation while studying the solution options for singular boundaries.

Subsequently, following this question, a complete theory of iterative domain reconstruction was established!

Now, Glenn Arthur actually says: Lin Feng doesn't understand Lin Bianjie?

That's fantastic!

Thinking of this, Wilson didn't bother to continue the conversation and said directly, "Professor Arthur, I think CPDE will no longer need you to review manuscripts."

These words stunned Professor Arthur once again.

"You don't need me to review the manuscript anymore? What does that mean?"

Wilson simply said, "It means exactly what it says!"

"From now on, the editorial department will no longer send you any new external review invitations!"

"As for the manuscript you currently have that is not yet completed, we will forward it to other reviewers!"

Now, Glenn Arthur was completely panicked!

It's important to understand that being able to serve as a long-term external reviewer for an internationally renowned journal like CPDE is itself a recognition of a scholar's academic level!

Moreover, after so many years of collaboration, countless people in the international mathematics community know that he is a senior external auditor at CPDE.

As a result, they've stopped him from continuing the trial. If this gets out, won't he be laughed at to death by everyone else?

From now on, I won't be able to hold my head up high, let alone at school or even when I attend an academic conference!

"Wilson! I admit there may have been some oversights in this review, but that doesn't mean there's a problem with my professional competence!"

"We've been working together for so many years, don't you trust me?"

"Believe? Professor Arthur, what do you expect me to believe in?"

"You've misread two manuscripts, even Lin Feng's own. What right do you have to make me believe you?"

"You know what? If I hadn't glanced at the author information for this paper, I almost would have sent a rejection notice to that math genius!"

"Do you know how much of an impact this would have on our journal if it actually happened?"

"You don't need to say anything more, Professor Arthur. This matter has been decided! That's it!"

After saying that, he hung up the phone without giving the other party any chance to explain.

Next, open the external reviewer management system, find Glen Arthur's name, and click Remove!

confirm!

Soon, this senior external reviewer, who had collaborated with CPDE for over a decade, was completely removed from the list of reviewers.

After dealing with all of this, Wilson did not relax.

Instead, he looked at the paper again and fell into deep thought.

To find out, who is the most talked-about person in the international mathematics community right now?

Without a doubt, it is Lin Feng from Jiangyang Normal University!

Just because of one of their papers published in Ariv, it triggered a massive investigation by the international mathematics community!

Numerous papers have been required to undergo review again!

Numerous authors have been asked to supplement forest boundary proofs!

Even their CPDE online submission system has added a mandatory field for "whether the submission meets the LinBoundary requirement"!

It can be said that—

The eyes of the entire mathematical community are now focused on this Chinese man!

And their CPDE actually has a paper by Lin Feng?

In fact, it seems to be the first paper the other party has ever submitted to a journal?

Without hesitation, Wilson immediately reported the matter to Professor Panos, the editor-in-chief of CPDE and a professor in the Department of Mathematics at the University of Chicago!

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like