Journey to the West: Please Call Me the White Bone Demon
Chapter 643 The Debate Between Buddhism and Buddhist Studies
The Black Bear Spirit was an honest man. Once he decided to become an apprentice, he knelt on the ground and banged his head three times with such force that the surrounding bluestone slabs cracked.
"Elder! I was originally a black bear who attained enlightenment. I lived in the nearby Black Wind Mountain. Since I gained intelligence, I have absorbed the spiritual energy of heaven and earth and the essence of the sun and moon. I have abstained from blood food and admired the Buddha's teachings. Later, after getting to know my old friend Jinchi, I have become more and more diligent in the path of Buddhism."
"Today I am fortunate to have met the Elder's compassionate guidance. Perhaps I should extend my mercy and accept him as a disciple, to serve him tea and water, to hold his whip and stirrup, all so that I may be closer to the Buddha's countenance!"
Xuanzang felt completely overwhelmed. Why did people keep coming up to him to ask to be his disciple wherever he went?
He looked at the black bear spirit, and finally shook his head, saying, "Get up, I cannot take you in."
"Why is this? This disciple...this disciple sincerely pays homage, only begging the elder to accept me!" The black bear spirit was anxious and kept kowtowing.
Upon hearing this, Sun Wukong scratched his ear, feeling that the words sounded somewhat familiar.
Xuanzang sighed and then said.
"I know you are eager to improve yourself, which is a good thing. But you admire the Dharma, while I study Buddhist philosophy. These are not the same thing, so how can I be your teacher?"
"Moreover," Xuanzang paused for a moment, then continued.
"I was originally a doctoral student at Jinshan Temple Buddhist Academy. I wanted to understand the differences between various Buddhist translations and also wanted to read the original scriptures. So I asked the state for permission and was approved to leave Wei and go to Lingshan for academic exchange."
"I haven't even graduated from a Buddhist academy myself, so how could I possibly be qualified to impart knowledge, teach you, and answer your questions?"
The black bear spirit was stunned after hearing this.
Is it because the high monk's language is obscure and difficult to understand, or is it because my own spiritual practice is shallow?
How come he can understand everything the elder says, but doesn't understand the meaning of it when put together?
However, he had followed Elder Jinchi in practicing Buddhism for many years and developed the good habit of asking questions when he didn't understand something.
"Elder, I don't understand. What's the difference? Aren't Buddhist teachings and Buddhist philosophy the same thing?"
Not to mention the Black Bear Spirit, even Elder Jinchi, who was watching the show from the sidelines, was somewhat confused. He turned his gaze to Xuanzang and waited quietly for his explanation.
Xuanzang smiled and said, "As the saying goes, a difference of a hair's breadth can lead to a difference of a thousand miles. Although there is only a one-word difference between Buddhism and Buddhist studies, they are completely different things."
"I would like to hear the details."
The Black Bear Spirit and Elder Jinchi pretended to listen attentively, adopting the posture of disciples.
"A single word makes a world of difference in intention."
"Buddhist scholars should examine the meaning of scriptures, distinguish between truth and falsehood, and sort out the principles; therefore, learning should be the priority."
"Buddhism emphasizes whether one believes or not, whether one accepts or not. It stresses relying on a teacher and experiencing spiritual responses, thus gathering followers through faith."
"Buddhist teachings require one to first doubt and then discern, while Buddhist teachings require one to first believe and then follow. Doubt makes one difficult to deceive, while belief makes one easy to command."
Upon hearing this, Elder Jinchi couldn't help but frown.
"Master Xuanzang's words were a bit harsh. In my opinion, doesn't Buddhism also teach people to do good?"
Xuanzang looked up at him and continued, "What you say is true, but being inclined to do good is one thing, and gathering faith is another."
"Just look at how he teaches."
"If a lecture is given in a place and no one is allowed to ask questions, but only repeated about how slandering the Dharma leads to hell and doubting the teacher is the most serious sin, and then wrapped up with layers of blessings, karmic obstacles, and rebirth in the Pure Land, then believers will not dare to think about it and will only dare to follow. The problem with Buddhism is not in its name, but in its methods. First, dispel their doubts, then win their hearts; first promise them blessings, then fear them misfortune. This is not cleansing their hearts, but is close to brainwashing."
Upon hearing this, Elder Jinchi couldn't help but exclaim in surprise.
"Old friend, what is the reason for this?" The Black Bear Spirit was pondering the reason when he heard Elder Jinchi's exclamation, which interrupted his thoughts.
Upon hearing this, Jin Chi couldn't help but sigh.
"Every word spoken by the Venerable Xuanzang is true."
"What do you mean by that?" the black bear spirit asked curiously.
Elder Jinchi said, "In the past, before I was enlightened by Master Xuanzang, I only thought about profit and money, and completely ignored the profound truths of Buddhism."
At this point, a look of shame appeared on his face.
"There was a lay Buddhist in the west of the city who was quite wealthy. He was somewhat of a Buddhist. One day, when he came to my Zen temple to donate money for incense, he asked me how my merits were going. I was just an ordinary monk, so how would I know what merits he had?"
"But when I thought of his family's assets, I couldn't help but feel greedy. So I said to him, 'Your sins in your past life were heavy. You must offer a thousand lamps and donate three acres of land in order to ensure the safety of your descendants.'"
"At first, the layman was somewhat surprised and uncertain. I then told him that if he did not believe this, it would be an even greater sin, and he would go to hell after death, or be reborn as an animal in his next life."
"A few days later, he offered the incense money and the land. When I asked him about it, he said that the simple-minded woman in his family had asked him if these things were recorded in the scriptures. He said proudly, 'The scriptures are profound, how could a woman like you understand them? Just listen to what the elder says, and you will be safe.'"
Upon hearing this, everyone looked at each other in bewilderment.
Elder Jinchi continued.
"At that time, I was still very proud of myself, thinking that I could make people willingly hand over their money with just a few words, which was really due to my high status. But today, after being enlightened by Master Xuanzang and hearing the debate between Buddhism and Buddhist philosophy, I was shocked to realize that this was a case of using the name of Buddhism to rob people of their thinking and money."
The black bear spirit looked at his old friend in front of him and remained silent.
For a moment, he didn't know what to say.
Previously, when the two sat down to discuss the Dao, he only felt that this person's Buddhist teachings were profound and that he was compatible with him in temperament. However, he did not know that Jin Chi had done such dirty things in private.
So the black bear spirit spoke to Xuanzang again.
"The elder has just spoken about the Dharma. If we discuss it from a Buddhist perspective, how should we proceed?"
Xuanzang frankly stated: "If we consider it from the perspective of Buddhist studies, it is quite different. Buddhist studies emphasizes reality. First, we ask which sutra it comes from, in which era it was translated, and whether there are any different versions. What are the commentaries? If the research shows that it is not based on factual evidence, but rather on the far-fetched interpretations of later generations, then the rhetoric will fall apart on its own."
"As the saying goes, Buddhist teachings are like a knife; they cut open the scriptures and also expose those who use them to deceive others."
After hearing these words, the Black Bear Spirit was stunned for a long time.
Elder Jinchi felt as if he had been struck by a profound truth, and chanted "Amitabha" several times, as if he had received some profound wisdom.
Even Sun Wukong and the White Dragon secretly pondered the underlying principles.
Although they had long known that their master was not going to retrieve Buddhist scriptures, but rather to the West for academic exchange.
But that was all I had in mind; I didn't know how to explain it.
Only today did I realize that although they were monks, what they practiced was not Buddhism, but Buddhist philosophy.
After pondering for a long time, the black bear spirit felt that all the Buddhist teachings he had learned over the past two or three hundred years were a joke.
When it comes to spiritual practice, Buddhist teachings should come first, with Buddhist doctrines as a supplement.
Thinking about it this way, my belief in becoming an apprentice only grew stronger.
He looked at Xuanzang with a resolute gaze.
"Master, please accept me as your disciple! After hearing your words today, I wish I could serve you morning and night, listening to your teachings every day!"
"this……"
Xuanzang never expected that his words, intended as a refusal, would ironically strengthen the Black Bear Spirit's resolve to become his disciple.
But then he thought, since the Black Bear Spirit had such an idea, it would be too heartless of him to refuse.
So he said, "Fine, since you sincerely want to follow me, then follow me. But I must say beforehand that with my level of skill, I may not be able to be your teacher."
The black bear spirit was overjoyed upon hearing this, and he couldn't hear the rest of the sentence. He was just happy and kept calling him "master" in his heart.
Elder Jinchi watched from the side, a hint of envy creeping into his heart. If he were a hundred or two hundred years younger, and if he hadn't committed those outrageous acts, he too would have wanted to become Xuanzang's disciple.
But now that people are willing to give him a chance to reform, he will only do what good deeds he can in Jinchi Temple to make up for the absurdity of the first half of his life.
You'll Also Like
-
Artoria's Journey to Slay Sisters
Chapter 71 8 hours ago -
Douluo Continent: My Martial Soul is an Aircraft Carrier
Chapter 221 8 hours ago -
World Designers
Chapter 385 8 hours ago -
Let me teach Katsura Kotonoha how to use a hatchet.
Chapter 108 8 hours ago -
What is it like to transform into an ancient god?
Chapter 210 8 hours ago -
Even slimes want to become evil gods.
Chapter 117 8 hours ago -
American comics: I can extract animation abilities...
Chapter 245 8 hours ago -
Minato Namikaze of Konoha, his ninjutsu is too abstract.
Chapter 279 8 hours ago -
Douluo Continent: Dragon Soul Descends, Riding Dragons to Slay Gods
Chapter 133 8 hours ago -
Clever Naruto Life
Chapter 328 8 hours ago