The atmosphere suddenly froze during the practical assessment at the training course.

Zhou Hongmei bent down to examine the needles on the patient's leg. "Dr. Buick, the Zusanli acupoint you just selected was off by one and a half inches."

Bek, a Kazakh village doctor, stood up; his nearly 1.9-meter height made him stand out in the crowd.

He stroked his beard and said in a loud voice, "Teacher Zhou, I've been practicing acupuncture in the pastoral areas for fifteen years, and this is how I've always found the acupoints. My patients all say it works well."

The students watching whispered among themselves.

Buick is the oldest and most experienced village doctor in the training program, and he enjoys high prestige in the pastoral area.

Now that he has openly questioned the standards of the teaching materials, the other trainees are worried.

Zhou Hongmei did not immediately refute. She pointed to the anatomical diagram in the textbook: "Look, the standard location is three inches below the Dubi acupoint, one finger-width lateral to the tibia."

"You stuck it two fingers too far out, and not deep enough."

"Textbooks are textbooks, and reality is reality."

Buick disagreed, "Herders ride horses all year round, their leg muscles are very developed, they simply can't get the stance right according to the book. I have my own experience!"

Their conversation quickly turned into an argument.

Buick insists that its method of locating acupoints "based on feel and experience" is more practical; Zhou Hongmei, on the other hand, emphasizes the scientific nature and repeatability of standardized operations.

Aygul tried to smooth things over: "Brother Buick, what Teacher Zhou means is..."

"I understand what Teacher Zhou means."

Buick interrupted her, turned to Zhou Hongmei, softened his tone but did not change his stance, "Teacher Zhou, I respect you."

But the diseases on the grasslands are different from those in the city, and so are the different doctors we have.

The assessment is temporarily suspended.

Looking at Buick's stubborn back, Zhou Hongmei realized that this was not a simple teaching disagreement, but a clash of two medical philosophies.

That evening, Zhou Hongmei knocked on the door of Buick's dormitory.

Buick was somewhat surprised, but still invited her into the house.

The room was simple, with several well-worn medical books and a pile of handwritten medical records spread out on the table.

"Dr. Buick, we don't need to argue about right and wrong."

Zhou Hongmei got straight to the point, "I want to conduct an experiment and let the actual results speak for themselves."

"What experiment?"

"You give me your experience-based acupoint selection method, and I'll use the standard acupoint selection method from the textbook. We'll find a group of similar patients and compare the treatment effects."

Buick's eyes lit up: "That's good, let the facts speak for themselves."

Zhou Hongmei continued, "Let's choose patients with rheumatism. It's a common disease in pastoral areas, and the symptoms are easy to observe and assess."

Buick slapped his thigh: "That's exactly what I was thinking. Our pastoral area has the most rheumatism patients; I have more than a dozen of them."

Zhou Hongmei already had a plan: "Then let's find more people, make it thirty in total, you treat half, and I'll treat the other half."

After three treatments, a third party will evaluate the effectiveness.

Buick laughed, revealing a set of white teeth: "Teacher Zhou, aren't you afraid of losing to a country bumpkin like me?"

"If your method of experience is truly better, then I should learn from you," Zhou Hongmei said sincerely.

The news caused an uproar at the training center.

The trainees never expected that a dispute over an assessment would escalate into a public competition.

Some people support Buick, believing that practical experience is more important than books; others support Zhou Hongmei, feeling that medicine must be standardized.

Aygul anxiously approached Zhou Hongmei: "Teacher, what if the result..."

Zhou Hongmei calmly said, "Medicine only looks at the effect. If Buick's method is indeed effective, what we should do is study why it is effective, instead of stubbornly sticking to our own opinions."

For the next week, Buick and Zhou Hongmei were both busy with their own things.

Buick selected fifteen patients with rheumatism, all of whom were herdsmen he knew; Zhou Hongmei selected another fifteen patients with similar symptoms to those in Buick's group.

Treatment has begun.

Buick's approach is indeed different from the textbook.

He doesn't use a ruler to measure acupoints, but rather uses his fingers to indicate them. Sometimes he even asks patients to move their joints so that he can insert needles at the points where muscles contract.

The needle angle and depth often differ from standard operating procedures.

While treating the patients, Buick explained to the onlookers, "The root of rheumatism lies in cold and dampness. I select acupoints that focus on the Yang meridians, use deep needles, and obtain strong Qi to dispel the cold."

Zhou Hongmei followed the instructions strictly.

She used a ruler to determine the position, marked it with a pen, and followed the standard for the needle depth, angle, and needle retention time.

She also explained to the trainees: "Standardization ensures the repeatability of each treatment. If it works today, it will work tomorrow, and it will work for other doctors using the same method."

Aygul took the initiative to record the details, meticulously documenting the changes in each patient's symptoms.

Maimaiti and Yeerken were responsible for the follow-up of some patients.

After the first treatment, three patients in Buick's group reported significant pain relief; two patients in Zhou Hongmei's group also reported significant pain relief.

Buick said smugly, "See? Experience pays off!"

Zhou Hongmei just smiled and said, "Let's see after three treatments."

After the second treatment, the situation began to change.

Of the three patients in Buick's group who initially showed improvement, one experienced a recurrence of symptoms; while the two patients in Zhou Hongmei's group continued to improve, and two more patients showed new improvement.

Buick frowned, but said nothing.

After the third treatment, Aygul produced the statistical data.

Thirty patients were assessed in a blinded manner by Maimaiti and Yeerken, who did not know which patient was in which treatment group and scored them only based on the degree of symptom improvement.

The result left everyone holding their breath.

Zhou Hongmei's "Standard Acupoint Selection Method" group: 11 people showed significant improvement, 2 people showed partial improvement, 2 people were ineffective, and the effective rate was 86.7%.

Buick's "experience-based acupoint selection method" group: 4 people showed significant improvement, 2 people showed partial improvement, 9 people showed no effect, and the effective rate was 40%.

Buick stared at the two statistical tables, remaining silent for a long time.

"How could this be...?"

He muttered to himself, "I've been treating rheumatism for over ten years, and the herders all say it's effective."

Zhou Hongmei walked to his side and asked softly, "Dr. Buick, think back, have the symptoms of patients who were treated effectively using your experience method recurred?"

How do you explain the ineffective treatment for these patients?

Buick froze, lost in memories.

After a while, he slowly spoke: "It's effective... but some relapse. I thought it was because they caught a cold again."

If that doesn't work, I'll say the illness is too serious, or tell them to go to a hospital in the city.

"Have you ever wondered why it sometimes works and sometimes doesn't?"

Buick shook his head.

"Because your empirical method lacks consistency."

Pointing to the statistics, Zhou Hongmei said, "It might be effective this time, but not necessarily next time. However, with standardized methods, as long as the diagnosis is accurate and the operation is standardized, the effect is stable."

She opened Buick's treatment records: "Look again, take a look for yourself. These five effective treatments were actually very close to the standard location, with an error of less than one finger."

The nine invalid attempts mostly had errors exceeding two fingers' width.

Buick took the notebook and carefully compared it with the anatomical diagrams in the textbook, his eyes widening in disbelief.

"Oh My God……"

He gasped, "I kept thinking I was adjusting, but actually I just missed the mark!"

The onlookers suddenly realized what was going on.

Zhou Hongmei addressed all trainees, saying, "So standardization is not rigid, but rather the optimal solution summarized from a large amount of practice."

It ensures that any qualified doctor can achieve basic treatment results.

Buick remained silent for a full minute.

Suddenly, he strode up to Zhou Hongmei, the tall Kazakh man placing his right hand on his chest and bowing slightly.

"Teacher Hongmei, I was wrong."

Zhou Hongmei quickly helped him up: "Dr. Buick, your experience is still valuable, but it needs to be combined with standards..."

"No, I want to learn from scratch."

I want to learn the kind of TCM practitioner who can explain things logically, like why this acupoint is located here.

Why this angle? Why this depth?

I want to know not only what happened, but also why it happened.

The classroom erupted in enthusiastic applause.

After the assessment, Buick did not leave.

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like