Chapter 524 Western Facial Paralysis

After the museum reopened on New Year's Day, major cultural and museum institutions in Europe and America sent in a series of applications, wanting to come and verify the collection. Following her father's instructions, He Nian remained firm and repeatedly turned down their requests.

The other party repeatedly tried to mediate through official channels and industry associations to secure a visit. He Nian insisted on not accepting visits from individual organizations, nor accepting any travel arrangements made before the Lunar New Year.

After much back and forth, it wasn't until after the Spring Festival that they finally agreed to allow the joint team to conduct on-site verification work on the eighth day of the first lunar month, February 24th.

This group was filled with anticipation, convinced that this trip would bring back the artifacts stolen decades ago to their homeland. Everyone had planned ahead, meticulously rehearsing the entire process—authentication, evidence collection, legal proceedings—in their minds countless times.

The core members of the joint team come from the British Museum, the Louvre, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and several medium-sized public museums. The team includes senior experts in cultural relics appraisal as well as veteran lawyers specializing in transnational cultural relics repatriation.

The group arrived at the park with expressions of determination.

He Nian, accompanied by the museum's legal representatives, received the other party in a conference room in the museum's main building.

The director of the British Museum, who was leading the European delegation, spoke first: "Ms. He, the purpose of our trip is probably self-evident. Many of the treasures on display in the gallery closely match the items stolen from our institution in the late 1970s. We hope to enter the gallery to conduct a close examination of the relevant exhibits, collect images and details of the objects, in order to verify their ownership."

He Nian sat opposite him, his expression calm. "Okay. The inspection is subject to scope restrictions and can only be conducted in the public areas of the exhibition hall. All footage taken is for the sole purpose of verifying this ownership dispute and cannot be used for any other purpose."

After a brief discussion, the other team nodded in agreement.

They believed that as long as they could observe closely, they could find remnants of old museum artifacts and obtain evidence that would stand up to them in court.


They examined old archival photos, comparing them one by one. The appearance of each exhibit matched the original theft record perfectly.

The expert team knew perfectly well that these were the things they had lost.

No matter how thoroughly they examined it, they couldn't find any original collection number or stamp on the back of the canvas, the inner lining of the frame, or the base of the object. The original markings had been professionally removed.

After three days of hard work, the expert team returned to the conference room with grim and unpleasant expressions.

They only have archived photos and written records from decades ago, which cannot prove that these exhibits are the same ones that were stolen back then.

After the inspection was completed, He's legal team moved several large boxes of documents onto the conference table.

The documents span thirty years. They include private transaction contracts, signed documents from long-time collectors, auction house transaction receipts, and customs entry records from previous years.

For each transaction, the time, people, and information about the collectibles all correspond, and the documents and procedures are complete.

Chief lawyer Zhou, representing the Ho family, stated, "All the transfer records of the collection are here. Mr. Ho Yu-chu acquired these artworks from overseas private collectors through multiple legal purchases. The entire transaction chain is complete, complies with Hong Kong SAR law, and also meets international rules for art transactions."

The Western legal team picked up the documents and examined them carefully. They randomly selected a portion, verifying signatures, notarization information, and customs records. After a long search, they couldn't find anything that could break this chain of evidence.

A lawyer from Europe or America frowned. "Many of the suppliers in these transactions have passed away. We can't verify the authenticity of the transactions in person."

Attorney Zhou responded, "From a legal perspective, notarized written documents are valid. The death of the other party does not mean the transaction itself is invalid. If you believe the documents are forged, you can submit them to a third-party judicial appraisal institution for verification."

The other team fell silent.

They knew in their hearts that even if they had the documents examined, they would most likely not be able to find any faults.

The atmosphere in the meeting room was heavy. The foreigners all looked frustrated. Everyone was convinced that the exhibits before them were the national treasures stolen years ago. But the law requires evidence; mere physical resemblance was insufficient to claim ownership of the artifacts.

The museum director leading the team spoke in a low voice: "We are preparing to initiate transnational litigation to determine the ownership of the collection through the courts."

He Nian gave a cold laugh. "You are welcome to file a lawsuit according to legal procedures. We have a complete set of evidence, ready for the court to access at any time. But I would like to remind everyone that transnational cultural relic litigation is a lengthy process, and the related litigation fees and appraisal fees are not insignificant. The lengthy trial process will also keep the global art community paying close attention to this matter."

These words added another layer of pressure to the other party's ears. Going to court not only costs money, but also means enduring public scrutiny. A loss could damage an organization's reputation.

The Western joint team requested two days of discussion, and after receiving permission, they began verifying the information through various channels.

The result disappointed them. The transaction chain for each item was genuine, specifying which collector it was purchased from, at what price, when it was shipped, and which customs it passed through—everything matched up.

What distressed them even more was that they had researched every single name of the sellers mentioned in these files: an elderly collector from Switzerland, an elderly lady from the Netherlands, a fallen nobleman from France, and an antique dealer from Italy.

These people were all real people, but they all passed away. The earliest one died in 1992, and the latest one in 2021.

The museum director leading the group took off his glasses and rubbed his temples.

"Their transaction records are more complete than our archives," he said with a helpless tone.

A French lawyer nearby chimed in, "Our problem is that the theft record is a paper file from the late 1970s, part of which was lost when it was being organized in the 1990s. The remaining part consists only of black and white photos and text descriptions."

The museum's identification markings were professionally removed, leaving no trace. The frames and hardware were replaced. Technically, there's no way to prove these are the same items we lost.

"The person who handled it back then?"

"They're all gone. The director in charge here retired in 1995 and passed away in 2010. We've contacted all the police officers who were involved in the case back then, but only two are still alive: one has a stroke and is paralyzed, and the other has Alzheimer's."

"Then what is our basis?"

The French lawyer flipped through the documents in his hand. "Archived photographs. We have archived photographs from before the theft. Judging from the style, composition, and signature, the painting in the exhibition hall is highly consistent with the archived photographs."

"Highly consistent, not completely consistent. Legally, it's not enough."

No one spoke in the meeting room.

Hillside villa.

He Yuzhu received a call from He Nian.

"Dad. Those people sent a letter."

"Are they preparing to pursue international litigation?"

"Yes. Attorney Zhou said that they probably know they can't win, but they can't save face, so they have to go through the procedures."

He Yuzhu nodded. "Let them go. Once the procedures are complete, they'll give up."

"Dad, what if they really sue?"

"If you're going to file a lawsuit, then you should respond. Is Attorney Zhou ready?"

"We're ready. Attorney Zhou said that even if it goes to international arbitration, our chances of winning are over 90%."

He Yuzhu put down his teacup. "That settles it then. Let's just wait. We're not in a hurry."

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like