Noon the next day.

A pop-up in-depth report appeared on the homepage of a mainstream media outlet in the provincial capital, with the title written in bold black font:

"Investigation into the losses suffered by farmers due to bureaucracy in Qingshun County".

The article begins by naming names directly in the very first paragraph:

"During the period when the price of Codonopsis pilosula was high, Qingshun County used administrative means to forcibly intervene in farmers' planting decisions and restricted the planting area of ​​Codonopsis pilosula, causing farmers to miss the best period for profit."

With prices plummeting and farmers suffering heavy losses, the county has introduced a guaranteed price agreement in an attempt to remedy the situation, which has been criticized as a case of "locking the stable door after the horse has bolted."

The text quotes policy documents used by cadres in Qingshun County during their door-to-door outreach efforts.

The article claims that the county "restricted the planting area of ​​Codonopsis pilosula through administrative orders and forcibly guided farmers to switch to other crops," omitting the wording such as "suggestion" and "guide" in the document and replacing them with "forced" and "order."

The article also specifically mentioned:

These policy documents were issued at the time when the price of Codonopsis pilosula was at its historical high.

"The county government was aware that prices were rising, but it artificially suppressed farmers' enthusiasm for planting, which is suspected of interfering with market freedom through administrative means."

A commentary was added at the end of the article:

"Qingshun County used the pretext of 'risk prevention' to carry out 'bureaucratic intervention,' which ultimately led to thousands of farmers being persuaded to withdraw from the market when prices were high and trapped when prices were low."

Is this approach to industrial governance helping farmers or harming them?

Less than an hour after the article was published, it was reprinted by more than a dozen media outlets.

Some local public accounts in the provincial capital also followed suit, some directly copying the full report, while others rewrote the headlines, using even sharper language than the original.

"Qingshun County: Restricting planting at high prices, shirking responsibility at low prices."

"You had the final say when planting was prohibited, but now you're indifferent when prices plummet?"

It was three o'clock in the afternoon.

The link has already been forwarded in various work groups in Qingshun County.

In the group chat where it was first posted, some people remained silent without comment, some sent a "Here we go again" emoji, and some asked directly:

"Who's messing with us this time?"

Someone also tagged the township officials in the group:

Didn't they say it was a "recommendation" when they visited the household?

How did it become "mandatory"?

The cadre who was tagged did not reply, but the message remained in the group for a long time without being pushed up.

He Ying's phone had been ringing non-stop since 2 PM.

First, Du Yuming called, his voice sounding a bit deeper than usual:

"Secretary, I've read the article; it's quite a force to be reckoned with."

They timed it perfectly—

It just so happens that after the price crash, when farmers' emotions haven't fully calmed down, that they brought up the issue of guiding and limiting planting when prices were high.

Looking back now, the farmers feel that the county initially forbade them to plant crops, and now it's ignoring them, leaving them at a disadvantage from both sides.

He Ying held the phone but didn't answer immediately.

What Du Yuming said was exactly what she was thinking too—

This article was not written on a whim, but was prepared in advance, and the timing was very precise.

Then Wang Desheng sent a message:

"Secretary, the documents cited in the article are indeed the 'Planting Guidance Suggestions' issued by the Agricultural Bureau to various townships."

However, that was a suggestion, not an order, and the townships did not have any coercive measures when implementing it.

They changed "suggestion" to "mandatory," which is a fallacy of misrepresentation.

He Ying did not reply after reading the message.

She knew in her heart that what was written in black and white was a "suggestion," but in the public sphere, once a label is attached, it is very difficult to remove.

Then, Liu Haiyan called, her tone noticeably more urgent:

"Secretary, General Manager Liu from Guangjitang has also been asking me about the situation."

The last section of the article mentions a guaranteed minimum price, saying that the county is using government subsidies to fill the financial gap.

Mr. Liu was worried that this wave of public opinion would affect the project's progress, and asked me if the county had any contingency plans.

He Ying said, "Tell General Manager Liu that the county is already handling it, and tell him not to worry."

After hanging up the phone.

He Ying placed the two documents side by side on the table—

The article is on the left;

The original document is on the right – a section-by-section comparison.

She discovered that the key wording in the documents cited in the article had all been replaced.

The suggestion to "appropriately control the planting scale" was changed to "mandatory restriction on planting area";

"Guiding farmers to plant scientifically" was written as "administrative intervention in market freedom";

The phrase "can choose to sign a guarantee agreement with Guangjitang" was misrepresented as "force farmers to sign an agreement".

She circled these differences in red and then added Du Yuming, Wang Desheng, and Liu Haiyan to a temporary work group.

He Ying spoke first:

"I've read the article; it's been reposted quite a bit."

This report was not written on the spur of the moment; it was prepared in advance—the materials cited were not readily available online, but required someone to spend time collecting and organizing them.

This is consistent with the previous methods used to manipulate public opinion; someone is continuously targeting Qingshun County.

The direction hasn't changed, but the frequency is increasing.

Du Yuming continued:

"So how should we deal with this? The timing of the article was very tricky, right after the price crash. Farmers are already feeling uneasy, and seeing such reports can easily sway them."

He Ying paused for two seconds, then added:

The core arguments of this article are twofold—

When prices are high, they enforce restrictions on planting; when prices are low, they abandon all control.

The first issue is that the townships have never issued any administrative orders to mandate planting restrictions; when they visited households, they said "suggestions," not "orders."

The article directly changed the wording, which is a factual error, and we need to clarify this difference.

The second question is that the guaranteed price is a remedial measure that is activated only after the price has fallen, not a complete abandonment of responsibility.

Farmers signing the contract is voluntary; there is no coercion involved.

She paused for a moment:

"You each handle the tasks according to your assigned roles."

County Chief Du is in charge of external communications. This afternoon I will have the Publicity Department prepare a statement of the situation. Please check the wording and make sure it is issued today.

Director Wang was responsible for organizing the original documents, retrieving all the policy documents and meeting minutes issued at the time, clearly marking the difference between "recommendation" and "mandatory", and sending them to the Publicity Department for backup.

Director Liu is in charge of liaising with Guangjitang and keeping General Manager Liu calm, so he doesn't feel that the county is hesitant in handling the issue.

Each of the three responded with a single word: "Okay."

……

Six o'clock in the evening.

The Publicity Department of Qingshun County Party Committee released a statement through official channels, titled "Explanation on Guiding the Development of the Traditional Chinese Medicine Industry in Qingshun County".

The entire article, less than 600 words long, is restrained in its wording and addresses each of the report's core accusations point by point.

First, the document issued by the County Agriculture Bureau was a "planting guidance suggestion," not an administrative order, and no coercive measures were taken by the townships in its implementation.

Second, the county's advice to farmers to control the scale of planting during periods of high prices was based on market risk assessment and was not "interference with independent management";

Third, Guangjitang's guaranteed purchase price is a commercial activity and does not involve government subsidies. Farmers sign contracts on a voluntary basis, and the county does not make any mandatory requirements.

Within two hours of the announcement, the number of reposts began to decline.

At 8 PM, Du Yuming sent a message:

"Secretary, that media outlet in the provincial capital has retracted the article."

He Ying replied with a single word: "Okay."

But I know in my heart that retracting the paper does not mean the end.

This is not the only report about Zhao Yike.

Next, the other party will continue to create interference through other channels.

There was a knock on the office door.

Xu Hui pushed open the door and came in, placing a glass of warm water in front of He Ying:

"Secretary, you haven't had dinner yet."

He Ying glanced at the time—8:10 PM.

She really forgot to eat.

"No need, I'll leave right away."

After Xu Hui left, He Ying picked up her phone and sent a message to Chen Dapeng:

"A report came out today, but it's already been dealt with. I'm fine, don't worry."

Chen Dapeng quickly replied: "I saw the news. You handled it promptly."

He Ying did not deny it, but the corners of her mouth curved slightly.

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like