Doctor: I was picking up the broken pieces at the hospital.
Chapter 35 Thesis Revision
Not long after submitting the paper, Lin Shu received an email reply from the Chinese Journal of Emergency Medicine.
The email subject was: "Notification of peer review comments from the Chinese Journal of Emergency Medicine regarding your manuscript 'A Case of ARDS Treated with VV-ECMO in Severe Pneumonia'".
Lin Shu opened the email, which contained the review comments from the two reviewers.
The document lists eleven suggestions for revision, ranging from "insufficient explanation of the clinical significance of the case report" to "insufficient citation of literature in the discussion section," and from "unclear description of ECMO weaning indications" to "numerous grammatical errors in the English abstract."
Cheng Qihang, standing behind Lin Shu, leaned over and glanced at the draft: "Eleven comments? This is already quite good for your first draft. Last time I submitted a paper, the reviewers gave me a full nineteen comments for my first draft."
"Nineteen articles? You've revised them all?"
"What could I do if I didn't revise it? It took me two whole months to get it approved," Cheng Qihang said. "Let me tell you, that's how it is with paper submissions. No matter how well you think you've written it, the reviewers will always find all sorts of flaws."
After carefully reading the contents, Lin Shu forwarded the email to Lu Xinjian.
Less than half an hour later, Lu Xinjian replied: "I've looked at the reviewers' comments. The first and fourth comments are quite correct; the clinical significance of case reports is indeed not fully explained. Regarding the fifth point about citations, I've sent you a list of references; just use that to fill in the gaps. As for the rest, you can revise them yourself. Show them to me again after you've finished."
Lin Shu copied the eleven suggestions for revision into his notebook and revised them one by one.
After making the revisions, he read the revised manuscript from beginning to end again.
But after reading it, he discovered a new problem: he revised it according to the reviewers' comments, and the revised article did look more complete than before, but it was also much longer, almost a thousand words longer than the first draft. The discussion section had swelled from two pages to three and a half pages, making it somewhat lengthy and more like a compilation of content simply to respond to each reviewer's comment.
Just as he was at his wit's end, the phone rang. It was Su Wan calling.
"Hello! What are you doing, Mr. Lin?"
"Ms. Su seems to be in a good mood today. I'm revising my thesis!"
"Hahaha! Of course I'm happy I don't have to work overtime today! Oh! My poor Mr. Lin has already graduated and is still struggling with his thesis."
"Ms. Su, I would be very happy to receive your call if you weren't so gloating."
"Okay, okay. Okay, enough joking around. How's your improvement?"
"Ugh! Don't even mention it. After all that revisions, not only did the quality not improve, but the article's length actually increased."
After he finished speaking, Lin Shu recounted the whole story.
"Hmm! Although I don't fully understand your research data, I think some things are interconnected. For example, when I face revision suggestions from clients, I try to digest those suggestions into my own understanding so that I can gain their approval when I explain them to them."
Su Wan's words made Lin Shu's eyes light up instantly.
He immediately realized where the problem lay: he was indeed revising the manuscript based on the reviewers' comments, but he hadn't truly internalized those revisions.
Therefore, the revised article is like a jigsaw puzzle. Although the pieces are put together, there are still large gaps in the middle, which is why it is not smooth to read.
Lin Shu excitedly said to Su Wan, "Ms. Su, you are truly my lucky star. Meeting you is the greatest blessing of my life."
"Hmph! I think your roommate Cheng Qihang is definitely not a good person."
Why do you think that?
"Look at you, you've only been in Shanghai for a short time, and you've already learned to be so glib. You must have learned it from him."
"What do you mean by being glib? I'm speaking from the bottom of my heart."
"Tch! Okay, I'm almost home. You can focus on revising your thesis! By the way, winter is coming to Shanghai soon, so remember to keep warm."
"Okay!"
After hanging up the phone, Lin Shu began revising his paper.
This time, he first made an outline and then reorganized the core logic of the article.
After clarifying this logical chain, he then revised the manuscript based on each of the reviewers' comments. However, he did not take the comments as a starting point, but rather as a point of verification to see if the problems mentioned by the reviewers were naturally resolved within his logical chain.
After revising it, he found that the article was not only reduced from 5,000 words to 4,000 words, but also read much more smoothly.
[Case report writing skills fragment (green) ×1. Source: The host's independent manuscript revision process.]
After checking it again, Lin Shu sent the second draft to Lu Xinjian.
That afternoon, Lu Xinjian replied to him: "You can submit it now. I've also revised the English abstract for you; see the attachment."
Lin Shu opened the attachment and found that Lu Xinjian had almost rewritten the English abstract he had written. Although the structure remained the same, the wording and grammar were completely changed.
He resubmitted the revised manuscript.
In the evening, a new patient arrived at the EICU.
A patient in his fifties suffering from cardiogenic shock developed severe heart failure after an acute myocardial infarction. Medication was unable to maintain his blood pressure, and he needed VA-ECMO to support him.
VA-ECMO and VV-ECMO are based on completely different logics.
VV-ECMO only replaces the function of the lungs; blood flows out and back into the veins, while the patient's heart continues to pump blood.
VA-ECMO replaces the functions of the heart and lungs; blood flows from the veins back to the arteries, and the entire circulatory system is taken over by the machine.
The VA-ECMO setup process went smoothly.
The moment the machine started, my systolic blood pressure jumped from 70 to 110.
Looking at this change, Lin Shu felt a strange feeling welling up inside him.
This machine is pumping blood in place of the heart of a man in his fifties.
Blood is drawn from the right atrium, propelled by a centrifugal pump, fully oxygenated through a membrane lung, and finally returned to the aorta.
It not only bypassed the entire pulmonary circulation, but also the collapsed heart.
This is as if a slit has been cut open in the laws of nature.
"The difficulty with VA-ECMO isn't in getting it on the machine, but in management," Lu Xinjian said beside him. "Because you need to monitor three systems simultaneously—circulatory, lung, and kidney. Circulatory systems rely on the machine, lungs on the ventilator, and kidneys on medication or CRRT. These three systems are interconnected; if one has a problem, the other two will also collapse. So what you need to do now is to monitor the data of these three systems every day and find the balance between them."
You'll Also Like
-
One Piece: The Navy's Lazy King, Kizaru Doesn't Hehe
Chapter 224 4 minute ago -
Hogwarts begins with the theft of power
Chapter 558 4 minute ago -
Immortal Rebellion: Reborn as Zhou Yi, Many Children and Many Blessings
Chapter 72 4 minute ago -
Beast Taming for Immortality Begins with Repatriation from the Mountain
Chapter 96 4 minute ago -
Wizards begin with the talent of replication
Chapter 83 4 minute ago -
Spring and Autumn Refining Master
Chapter 56 4 minute ago -
Just tell me that my holy water pipe didn't work!
Chapter 63 4 minute ago -
The Prince Consort of Zhenguan: Please address me as Your Majesty's beloved son-in-law.
Chapter 64 4 minute ago -
Artists Start in Prison
Chapter 252 4 minute ago -
First Hokage Uchiha Madara
Chapter 117 4 minute ago