I'm focused on passing the civil service exam, but you're trying to trick me into doing sc

Chapter 48 Academician: My award-winning paper was wrong too!?

Chapter 48 Academician: My Award-Winning Paper Was Wrong Too!? (4K, Please Subscribe)

"Has no one in China been able to find the errors in the paper?"

Inside the director's office at the Yenching International Mathematical Research Center.

The room was very simple and clean, with bookshelves along the walls filled with famous mathematical works.

Song Gang was sitting in a black leather chair.

At over seventy years old, his temples were completely white, but his back remained straight, exuding a rigor and composure cultivated through years of academic pursuit.

Hearing Zhou Shusen's words on the phone, he raised an eyebrow slightly.

Surprising!

But it was just surprise!

Having worked in the mathematics community for so many years, he has seen too many so-called "sensational achievements in the mathematics community", "overturning century-old theories", and "unassailable results".

Almost every so often, someone claims to have proven the Riemann Hypothesis.

He often received thick stacks of manuscripts from people who claimed to have overturned calculus and relativity, and even rebuilt a complete mathematical system.

However, the vast majority of them cannot even achieve the most basic logical closure.

Contradictory!

They're everywhere!

But today is different, because that's what Zhou Shusen said.

Although Zhou Shusen was still some distance from his academic level, the other party did have a certain level of academic ability.

Since they dared to send such a paper to me, it means that the paper has at least passed the most basic professional tests.

Therefore, he did not underestimate this paper; on the contrary, he became more interested in it.

I opened the paper, glanced at the title, skipped the author list to avoid being biased, and started reading directly from the abstract.

For the first few minutes, he barely moved.

He simply rested his right hand lightly on the mouse, his gaze slowly following the page downwards.

The content discussed in the paper was still easy for him to understand.

The problem lies in the fact that the fixed domain and pre-defined boundary conditions in traditional differential derivations are both problematic.

If there is preset information in the initial boundary conditions, it will affect the local steps and subsequent derivations.

That's the basic content, but the more Song Gang read, the more his brows furrowed, and he became very serious.

Because, as Zhou Shusen said, he did not see any problems in these lemmas and definitions.

Then, faced with a long series of deductions, which he considered to be logically closed loops, he still found no errors.

Therefore, he picked up the stack of manuscript paper next to him and began to check the calculations.

middle-

His assistant knocked on the door, but he did not respond.

When someone came looking for him, he did not receive them.

He even cancelled a scheduled internal discussion meeting.

He sat in the office the whole time, constantly checking calculations and making deductions.

The more you calculate...

The more I feel this is the right thing to do!

Of course, to verify a paper, one cannot simply follow the logic within the paper; the verifier needs to construct a new example to refute the paper.

He constructed it, but in the end, he found that he could not refute the paper at all. After the boundary was preset, the conclusion obtained by the traditional method could only cover one of the cases.

There is another result that meets the explicit conditions of the problem, but it was quietly eliminated throughout the entire derivation process.

Song Gang put down his pen, glanced at the draft paper, and checked it again.

The problem wasn't a calculation error; the entire process was fine. The real issue stemmed from the initial boundary constraint that wasn't fully defined—the boundary preset.

The first rebuttal failed.

Song Gang wasn't very surprised.

After all, Zhou Shusen himself said that, so far, no one in the entire Chinese mathematics community has been able to refute this paper.

Moreover, one failure proves nothing; any theory may happen to hold true under certain special circumstances.

He pulled out another piece of paper and asked a completely different question.

This time, he chose the area of ​​geometric analysis, which he is most familiar with.

We use geometric analysis to construct examples to verify this paper.

But as it turns out, the paper's content still holds true!

The second rebuttal failed.

Song Gang wasn't too surprised.

But a third time!

the fourth time!

The fifth time!

I tried three more times, but each time I could only conclude that "this paper is not wrong".

For a moment, he was no longer in a hurry to continue.

I stood up and walked to the window.

As you can see, the sky over Yanjing is rather hazy today, and the weather isn't very good.

Downstairs at the research center, you can often see a few students carrying books or backpacks passing by in the square.

-

He stood by the window for about two or three minutes before turning back to his computer.

This time, he started reading it from the beginning again, even more carefully than before.

However, no matter how you look at it, how you think about it, or how you calculate it, even using extreme cases, you cannot overturn this paper.

An hour has passed!

Two hours have passed!

A thin layer of draft paper had already piled up in front of Song Gang.

There were re-verifications of the core conclusions in the paper, and counterexamples he designed and constructed himself, but ultimately, all the verifications pointed to the same result, which was—

There are no problems with this paper!

The theory is completely valid!

At least by the means he could think of, he could not find any fundamental errors in this paper.

Song Gang took off his glasses, placed them on the table, and rubbed his temples.

Only now did a genuine look of horror appear on his face.

The entire paper, the entire argument, the entire derivation—it's all so complete.

No matter how you look at it, you can only believe that this paper is correct.

Moreover, discovering a vulnerability is not so terrible.

In the field of mathematics, there are many scholars who have discovered counterexamples by chance.

But most importantly, after discovering a vulnerability, find out why it appeared, how it spread, and what caused it, and finally establish a set of inspection methods that can be repeatedly used by other researchers.

This paper has achieved all of these!

This is what caused such a storm in his heart!

Thinking of this, he put his glasses back on.

I flipped to the very beginning of the paper and then started reading it from beginning to end for the third time.

If the first two times were to find mistakes, then this time it's for—appreciation!

I enjoyed this paper!

Enjoy the entire derivation!

You could even say it's about learning and seeking advice!

Moreover, this is not an exaggeration.

That's what he was thinking at that moment.

I was completely absorbed in this paper.

But as I looked at it, for some reason, a very familiar feeling suddenly welled up in my heart when I looked at the "hidden internal boundaries" section.

It felt like I'd seen a similar structure somewhere before.

As he thought about it, he closed his eyes and began to recall.

He quickly came up with an idea—

Fifteen years ago, he published a paper.

Uniqueness of Weak Solutions to Nonlinear Elliptic Equations on Four-Dimensional Manifolds with Degenerate Interfaces and Curvature Energy Quantization

This is a highly representative achievement in his academic career.

The paper studies a special space with a degenerate interface inside.

At that time, he proved that under the same external conditions and energy constraints, the equation could only have one solution that met the requirements.

Subsequently, based on the uniqueness of the solution, a complete set of quantitative laws for curvature energy was established.

This achievement was quickly recognized by peers both at home and abroad after its publication.

A few years later, he won the first prize of the Chinese Basic Mathematical Sciences Award for this.

Even today, many papers still cite its unique conclusions.

However, that paper also contains the internal degradation that this paper mentions.

And his handling of the situation back then —

Suddenly, he opened his eyes!

He grabbed the internal phone on the table and called his assistant.

"Academician Song?"

The call was connected.

"Go to the archives right now and find my paper from fifteen years ago, 'Uniqueness of Weak Solutions to Nonlinear Elliptic Equations on Four-Dimensional Manifolds with Degenerate Interfaces and Quantization of Curvature Energy.'"

"This includes the original manuscript, the first draft, the final version, and related supplementary materials."

"Oh, and also bring me all the application materials for the first prize of the China Basic Mathematical Sciences Award."

The person on the other end of the phone seemed puzzled.

"Academician Song, are you preparing any commemorative materials?"

"no."

Looking at the passage in the paper on the computer screen, Song Gang said, word by word, "I need to review this paper again."

Upon hearing this, the assistant was also taken aback, but without asking any further questions, he hung up the phone and immediately took action.

In less than ten minutes, the relevant materials were delivered to Song Gang.

Upon seeing these materials, Song Gang did not react immediately.

After staring at it for about two or three minutes, he pulled out the official manuscript and flipped directly to Part Five.

Part 5: Uniqueness of Weak Solutions

This is the most important part of the entire paper.

The subsequent energy quantification, solution structure classification, and stability assessment are all based on this conclusion.

If there is no problem with uniqueness, then there will be no problem with subsequent research.

If there is a problem with uniqueness, then all subsequent conclusions built upon it must be re-examined!

Upon seeing this, he quickly identified the problem.

Back then, to avoid a complex and degenerate interface, he first removed a small area near the interface, completed the proof in the remaining space, and then continuously reduced the removal area until the complete space was restored.

The method itself is not wrong.

The mistake is that when the inner region is removed, two new boundary constraints will form on both sides of the degraded interface.

Unless the states on both sides are specified in advance to be continuous and the energy transfer is completely consistent, the effects of these two boundary conditions cannot be automatically canceled out.

But Song Gang went through all his papers and related materials.

That point wasn't written at all back then.

In the most crucial step of proving uniqueness, he used the default condition.

At that moment, he was completely stunned.

Fifteen years!

The reviewers at the time didn't notice!

The subsequent award judges also failed to notice!

Later, countless scholars who cited this paper failed to discover it!

Even himself!

No one realized that they were wrong back then!

But thinking about it, this kind of deduction proves that the default habit has been used for hundreds of years, so who would have thought?

Even he wouldn't have thought of this if he hadn't read the paper.

But the author of this paper just happened to think of that!

Furthermore, based on this criterion, the logical foundation of his award-winning paper is flawed!

That's absolutely wrong!

However, he also understood that the reason no one had discovered it all these years was because the final conclusion was correct.

However, the entire derivation process has logical flaws!

Thinking of this, he couldn't help but sigh.

In fact, in his view, it's not terrible that this paper is wrong; what's terrible is that there may be far more wrong papers than just this one!

Therefore—

He looked at the downloaded paper for the fourth time.

This time, however, I only looked at two items.

One is the affiliation, and the other is the author's name.

Institution: Jiangyang Teachers College!

Author: Lin Feng!

After thinking for a long time, he realized he didn't know the school or the author.

After a moment's hesitation, he picked up the phone and called Zhou Shusen back.

As soon as the call connected, he said, "I've verified the content of the paper; there are absolutely no problems!"

"But I just want to ask, who is this Lin Feng? And where is Jiangyang Normal College?"

Hearing this, Zhou Shusen on the other end of the phone gave a wry smile and explained, "Academician Song, actually, Jiangshi is only a second-tier university, and this student is a freshman!"

Meanwhile, Song Gang wasn't the only one who, after searching for a long time, couldn't find any problems in Lin Feng's paper but instead found errors in his own.

This situation is common throughout the entire Chinese mathematics community!

Take the Tsinghua University forum next door as an example. An old professor who has been engaged in the research of partial differential equations for a long time could not refute Lin Feng's paper, but he casually substituted the iterative domain theory proposed by Lin Feng into his own masterpiece. However, he found that the conclusion in his masterpiece did not hold, and his masterpiece became a pile of waste paper!

The expert from Huaxia University of Science and Technology, who rushed back to school before finishing his family dinner, couldn't find Lin Feng's mistake. However, when he compared Lin Feng's paper with his own newly published SCI Q1 paper, he discovered that the domain had already shifted on page seventeen.

This phenomenon is not only reflected in academic papers.

A professor at Fudan University who had previously participated in the compilation of a textbook on partial differential equations discovered, upon comparing it with this paper, that his own textbook contained similar problems.

It wasn't just them; almost the entire Chinese mathematics community was the same.

They were originally looking for errors in Lin Feng's paper, but they couldn't find any. Instead, they discovered something else entirely.

They were wrong!

They're doomed!

Among them, the one who suffered the most was Jia Hu from Jianghan University in Hubei Province.

In the office, Jia Hu sat in front of the computer, looking at Lin Feng's thesis on the screen, his face extremely grim.

On his desk was a thick stack of documents, the cover of which read:

Study on the global stability of nonlinear evolution equations under complex boundary conditions

This project was a national key project he applied for, and he has been working on it for four years.

He invested several million yuan in funding, mentored more than a dozen doctoral and master's students, and published eight papers, including three SCI Q2 papers.

In two months, this project will be officially completed.

If he successfully passes the acceptance test, this achievement will become an important factor in his application for the next round of major projects and his selection as an academic leader.

But just then, Lin Feng's paper appeared!

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like