From being plagiarized and going bankrupt to becoming a gaming giant
Chapter 49 What does it mean to refuse to file a case?!
quickly!
The legal counsel replied.
The other party's actions did not constitute substantial infringement.
The probability of ultimately being able to claim a zero amount is likely.
Xu Yan was taken aback, somewhat surprised.
"What? Is there some mistake? This is such an obvious imitation, and based on the competitor's daily active users, the estimated sales should be at least a million in profit. How could there be no profit at all?"
That sounds a bit far-fetched.
Although Xu Yan didn't really want to get involved in this matter.
"Mr. Xu, based on our analysis of the game's modeling and art, this company is very clever. They've made subtle modifications to the parts they 'borrowed,' even extracting elements from seven or eight race car models and stitching them onto one car..."
The other parts that President Ji sent also carried the risk of similarity and infringement, but the other party had clearly made minor adjustments to the 'headlights,' 'wheel rims,' 'car paint effects,' and 'body camber.' In reality, it would be very complicated to investigate, and based on past cases, it would most likely result in a loss. Moreover, the other party's actual profit wasn't that much; most of their infringing modeling was... uh, given away for free..."
The legal counsel replied.
Legally, game plagiarism is only defined in two ways: art plagiarism and code plagiarism. Moreover, the process for determining cases of appearance infringement is quite complicated.
Regarding the legal determination of "plagiarism" and "borrowing" in the game industry: if there are some obviously novel additions, deletions, or modifications to the gameplay, which enhance the gaming experience, or if the game itself is of high quality, the court is more inclined to borrow, because plagiarism is malicious, while borrowing is a benign absorption and re-creation.
The other party's appearance model is visually almost identical to the pickup truck... but it's only 'almost'.
If you take it apart and examine it closely, you'll discover...
The other party's borrowing method is very clever. They even understand the characteristics and design concept of each vehicle better than the "original". They can freely and freely take the high-quality modeling effects from the pickup truck and put them on their own different vehicles, stitching them together seamlessly. In fact, the stitched effect is even better than the original...
This is a crushing defeat in terms of design philosophy.
Well...
The legal counsel team felt as if...
Are pirated versions more like the originals than the genuine ones?
In all their years as legal consultants, this was the first time they'd encountered such a situation... Piracy has a more creative design than the original? Then why bother copying? Can't you just create your own?
I only found out after a closer look.
So they were originally the original creators!
It was General Manager Ji's B2 studio that copied them first...
Wow! That's not surprising, not surprising at all.
That's the case, which raises another issue.
Plagiarism twice!
The court's logic is that copying a game doesn't constitute plagiarism... DinKart doesn't count as plagiarism because the game it copied was also copied. If Pickup Truck copied another game, the court might have to investigate the patent ownership, but unfortunately, it copied DinKart...
This is quite subtle.
It's worth noting that there have been similar cases before.
Previously, a knock-off game called 300 Heroes tricked a large number of male gamers and wealthy players into spending money by using extremely low-spec servers and terrible graphics. Later, it was sued for copying too much.
However, the final verdict was quite unexpected.
The lawsuit was dismissed.
Because 300 Heroes copied it so cleverly, it was similar in spirit but not in form. In addition, the official team used name changes to evade the infringement issue, such as renaming the character Kirito to Orochimaru and Orochimaru to Snake Uncle. Furthermore, it gave away a lot of freebies and won the hearts of the people. Ultimately, the court ruled that 300 Heroes did not constitute infringement.
Of course, this is just a local court ruling.
This again involves "local protectionism".
After all, these companies pay your taxes. If you don't protect them, and they go bankrupt, who will fill the tax gap? How will you handle the impact on unemployed people? What will other companies that want to invest think of you?
All the businesses have fled; do you still care about your political achievements...?
Therefore, considering all the complex factors mentioned above.
In areas where legal provisions are ambiguous, winning such a case is virtually impossible.
Without these "unspoken rules," companies like 300 Heroes wouldn't be able to plagiarize so blatantly and still thrive.
In fact, almost no original games have been created in China in the past decade. They all follow the ideas of their predecessors and add their own ingenuity, which is what Xunyou calls "micro-innovation".
"Mr. Xu, that's about it."
The legal counsel shrugged and finally signed the advisory team's review opinion—D-.
In Xunyou's evaluation system for its team of thousands of legal professionals, S-level cases are pure "revenue-generating" cases with low difficulty and high returns, which must be handled. From A to C, the difficulty increases progressively, but the return rate decreases sharply.
"Okay, okay, I understand."
After listening to the advisory team's review comments, Xu Yan waved his hand dismissively and casually flipped over the urgent document from Studio B2.
Fighting such a long and tedious lawsuit will incur significant litigation and time costs. The key issue is that there's no chance of winning, since it involves "secondary plagiarism." Even if you manage to win through some means, you're unlikely to receive any compensation.
As for the group level...
Game users are players, and players are people. People have moral judgments, and they know perfectly well who the legitimate players are. If you insist on suing, you will only damage your reputation, provoke player dislike, and even affect the future games of the group...
"..."
Xu Yan lay back down on the sofa and closed his eyes to rest.
It's not good for the group, not good for the legal department, and not good for Xu Yan personally. It only benefits Ji Yuan of Studio B2, and the key point is that Ji Yuan isn't even on his side...
Perfect timing, I'll do Gao Qiang another favor...
Legal professionals are quick-witted; after a moment's thought...
Xu Yan immediately sent the urgent letter back.
An internal response was also provided.
Minutes of the Preliminary Review and Feasibility Study of the Infringement Materials and Evidence Submitted by Lei Huo Studio Group - B2 Auxiliary Studio
"Reviewed! Our department has received and registered the document. After comprehensive assessment, the legal conditions for initiating litigation proceedings are not currently met. Therefore, we will not file a case at this time. We will reserve the right to pursue relevant prosecutions according to the progress of the investigation. For your review, General Manager Zhang, General Manager Wang, General Manager Song, and General Manager Ma..."
...
...
Studio B2.
"What does the person surnamed Xu mean?!"
"Translate this! What does 'denying the case' even mean?!"
Ji Yuan was stunned when he saw the reply to the email.
It wasn't just him.
Even the other directors at B2 Studio were completely dumbfounded when they saw this result!
What do you mean?
Are you guys just going to give up?
Their first reaction was, was Xu deliberately targeting us... After all, Xunyou's legal team has always been a bunch of insatiable mad dogs. They would pounce on even the slightest bit of revenue and bite hard. They take patent infringement more seriously than anyone else. But what about now?
All eyes turned to Ji Yuan.
You'll Also Like
-
One Piece: Starting by cutting Ace back to Windmill Town
Chapter 324 15 minute ago -
After the light disappeared: I played Ultraman Tiga.
Chapter 157 15 minute ago -
Trason Survival Guide
Chapter 844 15 minute ago -
The King of Raising Children, Starting from Sakura-sou
Chapter 320 15 minute ago -
Since becoming a doctor, I've always been inexplicably tempted by various empresses.
Chapter 329 15 minute ago -
Lady Vampire was not satisfied today either.
Chapter 705 15 minute ago -
Full-Time Magister: God-Level Sign-in Events Lead to Forbidden Spells
Chapter 252 15 minute ago -
The Witcher: Make the Witcher Great Again
Chapter 433 15 minute ago -
Marvel Police: Rebuilding Hydra's Glory
Chapter 255 15 minute ago -
Cultivating Immortals Across Two Realms: From the Azure Talisman to the Primordial World
Chapter 480 15 minute ago