The Wizard of Hogwarts is Unscientific

Chapter 715 What was the truth back then?
Harry doesn't like to brag like Ron, but he will show off some special experiences in front of his friends.

It is a characteristic of Westerners to like to show off and express themselves, and Harry is certainly no exception.

However, when it came to the matter of Dementors sucking away Voldemort's remaining soul, Harry was vague about it and never boasted about it from beginning to end.

This doesn't fit the character's personality at all!

Then the only explanation is that someone tampered with it.

Dumbledore!

He wanted to hide something.

Andy's thinking was clear. The fact that he wanted to hide it meant that Dumbledore knew about it.

If he didn't know, he wouldn't have thought of hiding it.

Dementors are associated with the dimension of death.

This was confirmed after Andy obtained the mirror that connected to the death dimension.

Plus the Dementors' abilities...

Absorb the joy! Absorb the soul!
Wherever Dementors appear, light and temperature will be absorbed by them, and the surroundings will gradually fall into darkness and coldness. All courage and hope will fade away, and fear and nothingness will gradually occupy the heart.

In a sense, this is the degenerated ability of the Grim Reaper.

"What is Dumbledore trying to hide?" Snape frowned.

"It doesn't matter what he's trying to hide."

Andy smiled, "The important thing is that he concealed it!"

"This proves that... he knows something, but he doesn't want us to know."

After a pause, Andy continued, "I will confirm this with Harry when I get back."

"What are you going to do?" Snape asked suddenly.

Andy raised an eyebrow when he heard that, "Of course, to investigate the secret of the Dementor's Kiss!"

You don't think I want to go against Dumbledore, do you?

"Professor, I must reiterate this!"

Andy said seriously: "The reason why I investigated Dumbledore's secret is just to understand the relationship between love and death from him... nothing else!"

"As for Dumbledore..."

"I don't care what kind of person he is, or what his purpose is. As long as he doesn't hinder my pursuit of magic, it has nothing to do with me!"

Speaking of this, Andy was also a little puzzled.

Why do so many people think I will deal with Dumbledore?

Do we have any conflicts of interest?

absolutely not!

I'm Dumbledore's favorite student!
——Andy Collins.

As for letting Dumbledore's soul explore the dimension of death... To be honest, if Dumbledore really had such a plan, he would plan a reasonable death for himself.

Andy didn't need to do anything at all.

But if not, Dumbledore is really a selfless saint, and everything is Andy's own malicious speculation.

Then it would be useless even if Dumbledore was killed.

That's why Andy needs to investigate!
Andy hopes Dumbledore has some plan, which will save Andy a lot of time and energy.

Otherwise, Andy can only rely on himself.

There is not even a single idea to draw on.

Snape: "..."

After hearing Andy's words, Snape was silent for a while.

When Andy first came, Snape hoped that Andy could calm down for a while and stop staring at Dumbledore all the time.

But now...

I will cry if I continue!

Snape was very clear that he was affected by Andy's words.

But he couldn't help being affected.

When it comes to Lily's death, he must find out the truth!
"It's getting late..."

Andy checked the time, stood up and said, "Professor, Voldemort's secret is very important to me. I'll leave everything to you."

"besides……"

"If the Ministry of Magic decides to perform the Dementor's Kiss on a Death Eater, please inform me, Professor. This is also very important."

"In exchange, I'll help you!"

After saying that, Andy turned and left.

…In the dim room, Snape sat quietly in a chair, with a somewhat uncertain expression on his face.

After Andy left, he reviewed the past that he did not want to recall.

Thirteen years ago...

At the Hog's Head Inn, he overheard the first three sentences of the prophecy and was then expelled by the owner of the Hog's Head Inn.

Overheard...

This may be his ability.

Or maybe... Dumbledore deliberately let him hear it.

Now think about it, considering Dumbledore's meticulousness, would he really leak such an important secret?
After hearing the prophecy, Snape couldn't wait to report the matter to Voldemort.

But Dumbledore did nothing about it.

At the time, he was able to stop it.

Even if you don't want to kill anyone, you can use Oblivion.

But he did nothing!

After some investigation, the child of prophecy pointed to two children.

Voldemort determined that the child was Harry Potter!

In order to protect Lily, Snape sided with Dumbledore.

He passed information about Voldemort to Dumbledore, and Dumbledore promised to protect Lily's family.

At the same time, he also asked Voldemort to spare Lily's life, and Voldemort also agreed to this.

Then, tragedy happened!
The secret keeper of the Fidelius Charm was Peter Pettigrew, of whom Dumbledore knew nothing.

This is unbelievable!
Lily, James Potter, Sirius and the others, they trusted Dumbledore even more than they trusted themselves.

Not only that.

Once the news leaks and Voldemort comes after them, Dumbledore is the only one who can protect them.

There was no reason why they shouldn't have told Dumbledore.

But the fact is, Dumbledore knew nothing about it!
After Lily's death...

Recalling this, Snape's eyes moved slightly.

After the Potters' deaths, Sirius hunted down Pettigrew and was arrested and imprisoned.

He was not tried, nor did he make a single appeal in his own defence.

Dumbledore never even glanced at him.

In this way, Sirius was imprisoned for more than ten years.

Waking up from his memories, a trace of pain flashed in Snape's eyes.

There are three suspicious points in the whole matter.

First, the process of hearing the prophecy was too coincidental, so coincidental that it seemed as if someone had deliberately arranged it.

Of course, no one knew what the prophecy was before it was made. Dumbledore was not a fortune teller, so he could not predict the future.

To say that it was deliberately arranged... seems unlikely.

But Dumbledore didn't stop himself!
"Doesn't he know I'm a Death Eater?"

This is impossible!!
The second is that Dumbledore knew nothing about the safe house.

This is also the biggest doubt.

Third, Dumbledore turned a blind eye to Sirius's affairs.

Snape frowned in thought.

Even if Dumbledore had made some plans, it should have been done after he heard the prophecy.

The power that Voldemort does not understand is love!

In this way, the first doubt no longer exists.

but……

Still the same problem.

Why didn't Dumbledore stop him?
Let’s leave the second doubt aside for now.

The third doubt...

Dumbledore would not be blinded by anger.

So... he really didn't even have time to ask a question?

Not to mention Dumbledore, even Andy... who had no friendship with Sirius at all, became suspicious of Sirius based on just a few clues.

(Andy: It has nothing to do with me!)
The more Snape recalled the past, the more suspicious he became.

What was the truth back then?
(End of this chapter)